Two Career Mistakes Marketing Students Can’t Afford To Make

Poets&Quants ·

Two Career Mistakes Marketing Students Can’t Afford To Make

François Bazini: “By all means, apply to the companies you love. … Just find out what you would actually be doing once you got there” Ask business students, especially those interested in ... The post Two Career Mistakes Marketing Students Can’t Afford To Make appeared first on Poets&Quants .

François Bazini: “By all means, apply to the companies you love. … Just find out what you would actually be doing once you got there”

Ask business students, especially those interested in marketing, where they would like to work, and certain answers need no explanation. Luxury, fashion, cosmetics, film, travel. Brands they admire, products they buy, experiences they would like more of.

Mention pasta sauce and the enthusiasm fades; by the time you get to payment infrastructure, they have a headache and haven’t even read the job description.

Marketing students have spent years discovering what they enjoy as consumers. Most have had far less opportunity to discover what they enjoy doing at work. Even those arriving at business school with professional experience have usually seen only a small corner of the economy. Their career ambitions often stay within those familiar boundaries, leaving entire industries unexplored.

“Follow your passion” can do real harm when students let their current tastes as consumers narrow their view of what they might one day love doing in the wider world of business. At twenty-two, they know they love films. They have probably never had the chance to discover how satisfying it can be to develop a product architecture or make a business grow.

Two career mistakes follow. The five graduates below are fictional, but draw closely on people I have known and situations I have encountered repeatedly throughout my career.

Take Chloé. She joins a prestigious global luxury house, working on lipsticks in the product marketing team of one of its brands.

Her friends are impressed. Her mother mentions it to people who have not asked.

She imagines creative debates, advertising shoots and helping shape the next launch. Perhaps she will even influence next year’s collections and makeup trends.

Then she discovers how responsibilities are divided. The famous and eccentric global Creative Director sets the brand direction. Communications develops the advertising. Product innovation belongs to yet another separate team. Many decisions she had hoped to influence are made at the Group’s head office in Paris.

Chloé spends her days comparing lipstick prices across competing brands. Within six months, she knows the price per gram of every prestige lipstick in Western Europe. She jokes bitterly that she has full creative control over the column widths in her spreadsheet.

Then there’s Daniel. He joins a regional pasta sauce company. He describes it to friends as “a good place to start,” in the tone people use for temporary accommodation.

His job involves working out why the flagship brand is losing buyers. He helps rethink its positioning, works with his boss to brief the advertising agency and recommends how to allocate the media budget. He works with R&D on recipes and builds the commercial case for a launch.

One recipe tastes excellent but costs too much. A new jar design looks great in the presentation but barely gets noticed on the supermarket shelf. Sales wants a promotion; Daniel must establish whether it will attract new buyers or subsidize existing ones.

He learns quickly, partly because people keep asking questions he cannot yet answer. He must defend his recommendations and live with the results.

Nobody asks Daniel about his job. This is unfortunate: he has considerably more to tell them than Chloé.

Much of what makes work interesting comes from the range of levers you can pull and the responsibility you are trusted with. A brand’s fame tells you little about either.

An industry can sell things you love while offering difficult conditions in which to build a career. Behind the experience may sit thin margins, weak growth and repeated reorganizations.

Consider Emma, who joins an airline imagining a career creating unforgettable journeys. She lands in catering procurement.

Her first negotiation concerns the unit cost of a chicken tray meal.

Soon, her days revolve around supplier tenders and contracts. Finance wants savings. Operations wants 800 meals at the right airport before departure. Much of the work would be familiar to buyers in a hospital or supermarket chain.

Her employer’s thin margins and cyclical demand leave little room for romanticism. A fuel-price spike or geopolitical crisis can trigger another round of cuts.

Emma admits, with some bitterness, that her airline’s route network includes places she has dreamed of visiting, but this afternoon she must establish whether the cheese portion can be four grams smaller.

Now meet Ben. He loves cinema and joins a company specializing in subtitling and localization.

He had imagined working with artists and like-minded people who shared his passion for cinema. His contacts are procurement managers and technical specialists. Some like cinema. Others could just as happily work in telecoms. His days revolve around file specifications, approval workflows and whether a delivery deadline means the files have been sent, received or validated.

His connection to Hollywood is a vendor manager several contractual relationships away from anyone holding a camera.

Both industries could suit someone who enjoys their demands. But neither graduate had examined the nature of the business behind the attraction.

More promising possibilities in unfamiliar sectors never made their shortlists.

Payments, perhaps.

Take Sofia, for example. She joins a payments company in a marketing role, accepting the offer after Netflix rejects her application. Her friends’ faces tighten and they lean back slightly, their expressions somewhere between anxiety and disgust. It is the sort of reaction usually reserved for a compulsory accounting class on a Saturday morning.

The work soon absorbs her.

Understanding payments means understanding how people spend and save, what they buy and whom they trust with their money. Developing an offer for merchants takes Sofia into questions about purchasing habits and why customers abandon transactions.

She learns how banking systems connect with telecommunications, what technology makes possible and how cybersecurity affects adoption.

Around her, banks, neobanks and payment specialists compete and form partnerships. Services such as Wise and Bizum prompt discussions about customer expectations. Soon, her boss mentions a role opening in another country as the company expands internationally. Responsibilities emerge that did not exist when she joined.

Sofia had expected a narrow financial specialty. She finds herself learning about much of the economy and the technologies reshaping it, and loving it. She feels she is working at the center of a major revolution.

Her experience illustrates what the others overlooked: business disruption, growth and innovation can give people room to learn and build their careers. Technology and changing buying habits generate work that needs people to lead it.

For the first mistake, look inside the job. Ask someone doing it to describe last Tuesday. Which decisions did they make themselves? What have they learned in the past year? Ask exactly which marketing levers you would control. Assess your future boss: could she be a mentor, and might her own progression open doors for you?

By all means, apply to the companies you love, too. Just find out what you would actually be doing once you got there.

For the second, investigate the business. Use business school to explore industries you cannot yet explain, rather than limiting yourself to companies you already admire because they make products you love. Go on a business safari with an open mind. Is the industry growing? Are margins healthy enough to fund new projects? Is technological change creating opportunities? Is customer behavior rich, complex and evolving, giving you fresh questions to explore?

We are living through extraordinary times. Across a vast economy, industries you have never considered – or even heard of – could offer fascinating work. After all, discovering them is also part of what you came to business school for.

Francois Bazini is a marketing professor at IE Business School in Madrid, Spain.

The post Two Career Mistakes Marketing Students Can’t Afford To Make appeared first on Poets&Quants .

Источник: Poets&Quants