Search Interest in Alleged COVID-19 Treatments During the Pandemic and the Impact of Mass News Media Coverage Based on Google Trends and Media Cloud Data: Retrospective Analysis
Journal of Medical Internet Research ·
Background: During a public health emergency, interest in unsafe or illegitimate medications can delay appropriate treatment and foster medical mistrust. Objective: The aim of this study is to assess the relationship between search interest and media coverage of 3 purported COVID-19 treatments: hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, and remdesivir. Methods: The authors obtained daily US-based Google Trends and Media Cloud data from 2019 through 2022, conducted national-level anomaly detection, and assessed the state-level association of treatment-specific search interest and media coverage by regressing search interest against daily media coverage, and vice versa, for each treatment using a 2-stage process. This allowed us to explicitly model the questions: (1) does a state have any of the outcomes (search interest or media coverage), and (2) given a nonzero outcome, how much is it impacted by the exposure? Results: Search interest and media coverage of all 3 treatments were significantly elevated during the study period. Anomaly detection identified several periods of higher-than-expected activity; anomalies in search interest and media coverage showed similar temporal patterns within treatments. There were distinct patterns of media source bias across treatments: while the plurality of top sources for all treatments were rated “Left” or “Left Leaning,” ivermectin was covered by the highest number of “Right”-biased sources, and remdesivir had the highest coverage by “Center” or unbiased sources. Significant associations between media coverage and search interest were observed for all 3 treatments. Media coverage had the strongest impact on same-day search interest for hydroxychloroquine (21.3% increase, 95% CI 20.1%-22.5%) and ivermectin (18.3% increase, 95% CI 16.8%-19.7%), and a more modest impact for remdesivir (12.8% increase, 95% CI 11.8%-13.8%). For hydroxychloroquine and remdesivir, this same-day effect was more transient, while interest in ivermectin remained elevated at a comparable level 1 and 2 days after media coverage. When evaluating the separate impact of search interest on media coverage, the associations were much weaker for all 3 treatments and all lagged conditions. Conclusions: During a public health emergency, the information accessed by populations can directly influence health-seeking behaviors, potentially resulting in life-threatening consequences. Given the observed associations between treatment-related news media coverage and public interest in those treatments, our results suggest that news media serve as a powerful mechanism for experts to inform the landscape of public opinion and to reach audiences during future public health emergencies. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): RR2-72212