Does Senate bill fast-track AI data centers and fossil fuel infrastructure, as Mark Ruffalo says?

PolitiFact ·

Actor and progressive activist Mark Ruffalo warned his social media followers about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act being considered in Congress, saying the bill to loosen the permitting process for major energy projects, including data centers, would harm the environment.

In the Nov. 18 video that’s been viewed 22 million times, Ruffalo said, “Democrats in the United States Senate are on the verge of handing Trump, Republicans and the fossil fuel industry a major legislative win by passing a bill that would fast-track AI data centers, pipelines, mines, power plants, and ICE camps, while sacrificing our clean water, tribal rights, public lands, and endangered species. If it passed, it would be the most severe and devastating rollback of environmental laws in American history.”

A day after Ruffalo’s post, the bill cleared the Senate , 62-33, with 14 Democrats and one Democratic-caucusing independent joining most Republicans in support. The vote sharply divided Senate Democrats: 30 Democrats and one Democratic-caucusing independent voted against it.

The legislation, which President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance vouched for in a Nov. 20 news conference, must win approval in the House to advance. The House could amend the bill, which would require the Senate to approve the new text.

The uncertainty over the bill’s fate, the potential for updated language and the difficulty of predicting how courts would interpret its provisions make it difficult to know with any certainty whether the scenario Ruffalo predicts will come to pass.

As written, the bill would ease the process of building major infrastructure — including data centers — by limiting laws historically used to block such projects.

It would also accelerate the adoption of low-emission renewable energy and require data centers to pay for their increased energy use.

“There are priorities that both sides want — it is not perfect,” said Juniper Katz, a University of Massachusetts-Amherst assistant professor of public policy.

Ruffalo’s representative did not respond to an inquiry for this article.

The bill’s sponsors — Democratic Sens. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island and Republican Sens. Mike Lee of Utah and Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia — designed it to speed up the process of securing approval for major infrastructure projects, particularly those for energy production and transmission.

The bill grew out of concerns from both fossil fuel backers and renewable energy supporters that opponents could stymie projects for years in the courts. With energy demand growing and electricity prices rising , supporters said a failure to build new infrastructure would consign the United States to a spiral of insufficient energy supplies and higher costs.

Critics of the bill say it effectively guts tools to prevent local governments and citizens, Native American tribes, and other local interests from blocking the harms caused by such projects. They also say the Trump administration, which refuses to acknowledge the possibility of emissions-driven climate change, could wield the law to advance fossil fuel projects over renewable energy infrastructure.

It has the support of some renewable energy groups such as the Solar Energy Industries Association and the AFL-CIO labor union, the American Petroleum Institute and the Edison Electric Institute , which represents utilities.

Groups opposing the bill include the Sierra Club , the Natural Resources Defense Council , the Climate Justice Alliance , a range of tribal organizations , the NAACP and the American Civil Liberties Union .

Certain laws that have long been used to oppose big projects — including the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, the National Historic Preservation Act and the Endangered Species Act — would be pared back if the new law is enacted.

The Natural Resources Defense Council’s analysis concluded that under the bill, a court “can never invalidate a permit” based on a violation of the National Environmental Policy Act or the National Historic Preservation Act, “no matter how severe it finds a legal violation to be.” It also found that the bill would exclude certain types of environmentally harmful activities from review and limit who can bring a case.

In most cases, the bill would prevent federal agencies from canceling, suspending or changing federal permits for projects that have received all necessary permits.

“It is reasonable to be concerned that the development of each of the kinds of projects (Ruffalo) mentioned could be facilitated by this bill,” said Geoffrey Henderson, a University of Michigan assistant professor of environmental policy and planning.

Opponents also worry the bill could allow the Trump administration to lock in fossil fuel projects or data centers without enough opportunity for opponents to challenge them.

“If the Trump administration issued a blanket grant of all permits for oil and gas infrastructure without any environmental review, the bill provides no clear mechanism for a future administration to revoke those permits,” the NRDC analysis says.

As for Ruffalo’s reference to detention facilities for Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the bill does not directly address those, but opponents of the bill say their concerns stem from the use of the National Environmental Policy Act to oppose ICE facilities in court in Maryland , Arizona and Florida .

Although the Natural Resources Defense Council opposes the bill in its current form, its analysis devotes almost 1,000 words to describing what it considers the bill’s positive features, including:

One of the bill’s highest-profile supporters is The New York Times columnist Ezra Klein, who is considered left of center politically.

In a recent column , Klein said he was “unnerved” by conflicting interpretations over what certain provisions of the bill mean, but still supported it.

“The problem, right now, is that we cannot meet enough new demand — whether from data centers or electric vehicles or heat pumps or anything else — with renewables,” Klein wrote. “What the act might make possible is the construction of an energy grid where there is enough renewable power to meet new demand. In the absence of that energy system, new demand would be met by fossil fuels. And the absence of that system describes our reality today.”

The bill could also boost non-energy projects that have faced long-running challenges in the courts, Klein wrote, including rail and transit , affordable housing and broadband access.

Ultimately, Henderson said, the bill’s impacts “are highly uncertain, depending on a mix of political outcomes (who controls the federal government and what decisions they make), market outcomes (competition between electricity sources domestically), geopolitical outcomes (such as global demand for the United States’ oil and gas exports), and legal outcomes (courts’ interpretation of the law).”

Источник: PolitiFact