Does mushroom coffee deliver on its health promises? Unpacking 5 selling points

PolitiFact ·

Does mushroom coffee deliver on its health promises? Unpacking 5 selling points

A warm, aromatic cup of coffee can be a reliable, flavorful pick-me-up. In recent years, online influencers have promoted pairing it with an unlikely counterpart: mushrooms.

“I’m on a mission to stop getting that afternoon crash from coffee that makes me want a second cup,” said an influencer advertising mushroom coffee on Instagram in January. She extolled its purported virtues, saying, “it promotes gut health and your overall immune support” and blended mushrooms that are “really good for your focus and energy.”

Mushroom coffee can refer to a mixture of instant coffee and varying powdered mushroom extracts or powdered mushrooms with other ingredients and no coffee.

As for the taste of coffee combined with mushroom powder, “interestingly enough, mushroom coffee tastes pretty similar to regular coffee,” registered dietitian Beth Czerwony told the Cleveland Clinic .

Although people might not taste the mushrooms in the coffee, they could notice the difference in their wallets. A 7- or 8-ounce container of instant coffee typically sells for less than $10 , and a similar amount of mushroom coffee generally costs $15 to $35.

For some people, paying extra is an easy trade-off for certain health benefits. But is mushroom coffee bringing those benefits?

Limited scientific research shows that consuming certain mushrooms might have health benefits. However, almost all of that research has been in labs or animals, rather than clinical experiments designed to evaluate the mushrooms’ effects on humans.

We found no studies evaluating mushroom coffee’s purported health benefits.

Nicholas Money, a Miami University biology professor who studies fungi, said he knows of no evidence that mushroom coffee has any positive effects on physical or mental health. For that reason, he said: “I don’t think it’s worth your time or money.”

But Toby Amidor, a registered dietician and nutrition expert, said there are no drawbacks to drinking mushroom coffee.

Most research showing health benefits from mushrooms looked at both the mushroom and its root-like structures. If buying “mushroom coffee,” Amidor recommended purchasing products that contain both.

Mushroom coffee can also fall into the loosely regulated category of dietary supplements, so there’s no way to know with certainty that you’re getting the mushroom extracts advertised on the packaging — or how much the product contains.

Here are some facts about the most-repeated mushroom coffee selling points.

Facts: Mushroom coffee can be decaffeinated, but it often contains some caffeine — just less than a standard cup of coffee because some of the brew is mushroom powder . Swapping standard coffee for mushroom coffee might help reduce or prevent caffeine crash-related headaches, fatigue or irritability, but there’s no clear evidence that any mushrooms in the blend would be responsible.

That caffeine reduction might help many people who are especially caffeine sensitive, Aisling Daly, a nutrition lecturer at Oxford Brookes University, said in 2024 on the BBC’s “Sliced Bread” podcast .

It’s possible the mushrooms themselves might have properties that reduce the effects of a caffeine crash, she said, but “we don’t know enough about what these mushroom powders can do.”

Facts: Incorporating mushrooms into a regular diet can change the composition of a person’s gut microbiome , research shows. The gut microbiome is the unique microscopic ecosystem of organisms including bacteria, viruses, fungi and parasites in a person’s digestive system. It breaks down fiber and starch and synthesizes vitamins, amino acids and fatty acids that help prevent disease.

There’s a lot we don’t know about the gut microbiome, but some bacteria are known to be beneficial, and some research shows that whole mushroom powders can increase the gut microbiome’s population of bacteria with known health benefits.

This research wasn’t specifically on mushroom coffee, however.

“Promising research suggests that mushrooms may support gut health, but there is not yet sufficient evidence to say that drinking mushroom coffee improves gut health in humans,” Amidor said.

Facts: Mushrooms and mushroom extracts can influence immune reactions — some stimulate immune function while others suppress it, and some increase inflammatory responses while others decrease them .

Much of the marketing around mushroom coffee says it “supports” immunity, but doesn’t make clear, specific claims about how.

“Our bodies react to fungi if they’re present in our diet in any form,” Money said, so it’s unsurprising that people have an immune reaction to mushrooms. “But whether or not that plays any useful role in health and well being? That’s very questionable.”

Facts: Some research has associated mushroom consumption with improved cognitive performance or with nerve cell growth.

A 2022 study found that older adults who reported higher mushroom intake scored better on cognitive function tests, signaling that regular mushroom consumption might benefit brain function .

Money said lion’s mane mushrooms produce a specific chemical compound that has been shown to speed up nerve cell growth when cells are grown in a petri dish in a lab. Other studies have shown that rats fed high doses of the compounds show brain chemistry changes, he said.

However, clinical studies on humans “really show no effect whatsoever” on focus and concentration or ability to complete intellectual tasks, Money said.

Also, there’s no research suggesting that mushroom coffee in particular can provide any cognitive benefits.

Facts: There’s no reason to think mushroom coffee is unsafe when consumed in moderation.

At high doses, certain medicinal mushrooms might pose health risks, but mushroom extracts are typically present in small amounts when consumed in mushroom coffee, Money said. So if it seems to provide benefits that outweigh its higher price tag, mushroom coffee might be a useful purchase — even if it’s the power of the placebo effect, he said.

That said, there are some health considerations. Some mushrooms can raise the risk of bleeding or interact negatively with certain drugs. Mushrooms can also be high in oxalates , which can cause problems for people with kidney issues.

PolitiFact Staff Researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report.

RELATED: Could that energy drink buzz be risky for your heart? Here’s what new research says

Источник: PolitiFact