The Army is going to detonate toxic lead azide in Iowa. Here’s what we know about safety concerns.
PolitiFact · · g5101170
The U.S. Army is planning two controlled detonations of 68 drums of toxic lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown on Nov. 20.
The operation, scheduled for noon local time, is expected to send a plume of lead dust into the air that may travel dozens of miles from the explosion site and could coat the surface of property, agricultural land and waterways in the toxic metal.
Officials told residents in two Middletown neighborhoods to evacuate because the force of the explosions may cause window damage. But residents in Middletown, which has about 320 residents , and as far away as Illinois expressed concern on social media about far more than broken windows.
“Hey @grok can you confirm if the U.S. Army is detonating a toxic iron azide bomb in my state that could cause widespread lead poisoning this Friday?” one X user asked .
“Is the Army about to unnecessarily poison Iowa and our Nationwide food supply?” another post on X wondered .
The Army said it is taking the action because the material is too dangerous to move or leave intact, and any impact from the blasts should be minimal. It said it was prepared for any necessary cleanup from the expected plume of lead dust.
Still, experts warned there’s no safe level of interaction with lead, and said farmers in the heavily agricultural state should take steps to protect the food supply. Some residents and politicians have called for the detonation to be postponed.
The Army said it determined in March that the stockpile of lead azide has experienced “severe chemical degradation and crystallization” over time and the drums would be too dangerous to move without the risk of explosion.
Leaving them in place and doing nothing also carries an ongoing risk of “uncontrolled explosion,” the Army said.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on Nov. 13 issued an emergency permit for the planned detonation.
That will depend on weather conditions. The Army released two maps, one showing where lead dust could be airborne and another showing where dust could settle.
It’s expected to release new maps six hours before the detonation, updated with current weather conditions.
Illinois officials warned residents in Mercer County, 55 miles northeast of Middletown, they could be impacted by the planned blasts.
That is also unclear, but the Army has sought to alleviate concerns.
When lead azide is detonated properly, the Army said in a question-and-answer page, “the intense heat incinerates the explosive material.”
It said sampling will be conducted before and after the blasts to determine if any material needs to be cleaned up.
“After the explosive hazard is neutralized, environmental teams will test the area, remove any contaminated soil, and dispose of it according to EPA regulations,” the Army said
The Army determined that any air quality effects will be minor and short-term.
“The map released by the Army is the worst-case scenario,” said Virgil Schmitt, an Iowa State University field agronomist. “It assumes all of the lead in all barrels will become airborne, which it will not.”
Some health officials warned to avoid any contact with lead, and some politicians said the plan should be postponed.
“There is no safe level of lead in the body, and when inhaled or swallowed, it can pose serious health risks,” Dr. Sameer Vohra, director of the Illinois Department of Public Health, said in a news release about the blasts.
Iowa Democratic Gov.-elect Rob Sand called for postponement, saying in an X post , “An unacceptable lack of communication and clarity has made Iowans understandably concerned and angry about this situation.” Current Republican Gov. Kim Edwards said her office only learned of the plan on Nov. 16.
Democratic U.S. Sen.-elect Josh Turek also said the plan should be postponed until more health information can be gathered.
Iowa state Rep. Gary Mohr, R-Bettendorf, also proposed a postponement, saying constituents in his town about 85 miles away were scared, the Des Moines Register reported .
The Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter filed a lawsuit Nov. 19 challenging the EPA’s emergency permit.
Patrick Wall, an Iowa State University beef field specialist, said contaminated feed eaten by livestock can transfer to meat products, but proper testing can help safeguard the food supply.
“Producers have accurate methods to test feed stored outside, and we’re recommending they do that prior to feeding,” Wall said.
Wall said a simple blood test can detect lead levels in animals, and the meat industry can also test for lead.
“Once the blast debris zone is defined, we can test feed products in that zone to eliminate risks to the food supply,” he said.
Wall suggested removing livestock from grazing areas that may be affected, and keeping them inside, among other precautions.
The Iowa Department of Agriculture and Land Stewardship issued guidance to livestock producers, including washing buildings and equipment afterward and monitoring livestock for acute lead poisoning.
Schmitt downplayed the risks to crops from soil, saying that lead is found naturally in soil and that plant uptake of lead is very small, regardless of the source.
PolitiFact Staff Researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report.