Biden’s fault? Trump’s fault? Fact-checking the partisan blame game about the FAA ground stop

PolitiFact ·

Biden’s fault? Trump’s fault? Fact-checking the partisan blame game about the FAA ground stop

As airlines work to recover from the Federal Aviation Administration’s nationwide ground stop Nov. 13, Democrats and Republicans are blaming each other for the interruption.

The rare nationwide freeze snarled air travel across the country. Trump administration officials have said a routine router upgrade — part of the FAA’s system changes — overloaded the older system. The agency announced it was pausing router installation while it investigates the outage.

President Donald Trump, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and conservative critics accused former President Joe Biden’s administration of mismanaging funds and failing to prioritize aviation infrastructure upgrades.

Democrats countered that the Trump administration was deflecting responsibility for a situation that occurred after nearly two years of uniform Republican control of the federal government, and after Congress had allocated billions of dollars for FAA upgrades.

However, blaming either political party ignores the full context. There’s a paper trail dating back more than two decades documenting delays and other problems with modernizing the nation’s air traffic communications system — and these occurred during presidencies and Congresses controlled by both parties.

“Modernization programs can take years to move from planning and procurement through testing and deployment,” said Mike O’Donnell, a former senior FAA official who is now a consultant and an adjunct professor at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University. Frequent turnover in leadership makes it hard to maintain priorities and accountability across programs, he said.

About a day after the ground stop was lifted, Trump said the Biden administration’s FAA was a “disaster.”

“Everything they touched turned bad. Big money spent unwisely, making an old and broken system worse than when they began,” Trump wrote Nov. 15 on Truth Social. He told reporters that Biden’s transportation secretary, Pete Buttigieg, “totally ruined it.” (Buttigieg pushed back on that criticism.)

“The Democrats really — it’s very old — but what they did really set back the system a long way,” Trump said.

When PolitiFact contacted the White House for further details, a spokesperson referred us back to the president’s comments.

Available public records, including audits and FAA investigations, do not substantiate Trump’s claims that the Biden administration made the system worse or improperly wired copper into fiber.

This isn’t the first time Trump has said the Biden administration wasted money in its FAA upgrade. After a Cabinet meeting in July 2025, he said the administration had hundreds of contractors hooking “copper into fiber, into steel” and other systems, spending “billions of dollars” that worsened things.

To attribute the outage to the Biden administration, O’Donnell said, “I’d want to see evidence that a specific decision affected the system that failed, its safeguards, or the FAA’s ability to respond.” That evidence hasn’t surfaced, he said.

At the same 2025 Cabinet meeting, Duffy said Biden’s FAA signed a 15-year contract with an American company “to fix the copper to fiber,” and that “the system is failing today.”

His comments referred to the agency’s longrunning initiative to replace its 1980s-era telecommunications network with a modern system, which includes swapping aging copper cables across thousands of facilities with fiber optic wires.

A spokesperson for Buttigieg’s political action committee, Win the Era, pointed PolitiFact to a 2023 contract FAA signed with telecommunications company Verizon to lead the system’s upgrade. The deal was a 15-year agreement valued at up to $2.4 billion, with the last five years structured as optional one-year renewals for maintenance and support.

The FAA under Trump restructured the contract in August, switching to AT&T as the lead project manager to speed up the system’s deployment. Verizon assumed a supporting role.

The revamped contract started with an initial $74.3 million planning and development order, but FAA said it anticipates it to rise to a “multi-billion” contract for “a period of performance of up to 15 years.” It’s unclear how much money was already spent from the initial contract, or how much this one will cost once completed.

FAA’s modernization struggles have spanned several Democratic and Republican administrations and congresses, with aviation specialists noting issues stemming from the early 2000s, during President George W. Bush’s first term.

Democrats have pointed to Trump’s 2025 signature tax and spending legislation, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, saying it provided the department with billions of dollars.

U.S. Rep. Rosa DeLauro, D-Conn., the top Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee, said in a Nov. 15 statement that the FAA has “received historical and monumental investments over the last two years, over $12.5 billion” and it “largely remains unspent.”

DeLauro cited an accurate appropriation figure — but she exaggerated how much money is specifically for the communications upgrade.

Of the $12.5 billion provided in the law, $4.75 billion was earmarked for “telecommunications infrastructure modernization and systems upgrades.” The rest of the money was for other purposes, including radar system replacements, runway safety technologies and construction of a new air route traffic control center.

The Transportation Department told PolitiFact that Duffy has consistently asked for funding for new software. In July 2025, Duffy said system upgrades are “a massive project” and that the sum provided by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act “is not enough.”

The Office of Management and Budget and the Transportation Department told PBS that the FAA has enough funds today to complete the switch from copper to fiber, and that the transition is about 70% complete. Duffy said on CNN’s “State of the Union” on Nov. 15 that “we are on track to have all of that $12.5 billion spent and deployed by the end of 2028.”

Before he was Transportation secretary, Duffy questioned the need for more money. “They got billions of dollars, the FAA did, over COVID,” Duffy, then a former member of Congress, said on Fox News in January 2023, shortly after an earlier FAA ground stop. “And now they’re gonna come back and say, ‘We want even more money to fix this crisis that we weren’t able to handle when, you know, for what, three hours in the morning aircraft couldn’t, couldn’t fly.’”

Experts said it’s not unusual for money to be spent in increments rather than all at once, because projects may need to be completed in phases.

“While more money may be necessary, you don’t need it all at once — that is a recipe for waste,” said Steve Ellis, president of Taxpayers for Common Sense, which tracks the federal budget. “It took a long time for these problems to develop, and it is going to take a while to fix them.”

Shortly after Trump began his second term in early 2025, his administration pursued a wide-ranging effort to cut government jobs and spending via the Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, led by billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk.

“You remember when Elon Musk was standing on a stage spinning his chainsaw around, cutting government willy-nilly?” U.S. Rep. Jim Himes, D-Conn., said Nov. 15 on CBS News’ “Face the Nation.” “Well, part of that chainsaw got 1,300 employees of the FAA to resign or to retire. They fired 400 probationary employees. … What you’re seeing is the wages of what Elon did, where he just gutted an entity that — that affected millions of Americans last Friday.”

Himes’ count of employees fired is broadly in line with the numbers reported by media outlets. But drawing a straight line from those cuts to the ground stop is speculative at best.

The 400 employees who were fired in early 2025 were “the types of workers tasked with helping aircraft safety inspectors, repairing air traffic control facilities and updating digital maps that pilots use in flight,” The Associated Press reported in February 2025.

It’s unclear how many would have been involved in the communications upgrade, which was handled largely by contractors.

RELATED : In Congress, did Sean Duffy vote against upgrading air traffic control systems? Here’s what we know

RELATED: Did Trump’s FAA slash the staffing target for air traffic control?

Источник: PolitiFact