Designing Better Collaborative Learning for a Neurodiverse World

Teaching + Learning Lab ·

Designing Better Collaborative Learning for a Neurodiverse World

On Thursday, October 15, two members of the Elon University Center for Engaged Learning Research Seminar Group, aka the “Collaborative Wombats,” Anne Marshall, Associate Director for Research & Evaluation at MIT Teaching + Learning Lab, and Christena Gunther, Assistant Director of Disability Services & Student Affairs for Adler University, presented findings from a qualitative interview study on collaborative learning that works for all students.

Beginning in summer 2024, the “ collaborative wombats 1 ,” (a playful nod to their Australian colleague who often faced significant time-zone challenges) came together to examine how neurodivergent students experience collaborative learning in higher education. This work was part of a larger three-year summer research program hosted by Elon University’s Center for Engaged Learning and focused on affirming and inclusive learning for neurodivergent students. A more detailed report will be published in an open-access book through Elon’s CEL in 2027. The research team can be contacted at collaborative.wombats@gmail.com .

This research focused on collaborative learning (CL) defined as learning activities in which students work together to complete educational goals. This definition aligns with Barkley, Cross, and Major’s handbook Collaborative Learning Techniques (Barkley et al., 2014) and encompasses the wide range of CL activities in which undergraduate and graduate students participate, such as in-class activities, semester-long group projects, internships, or research groups, etc.

“Neurodiversity” is the idea that people experience the world and interact with others in different ways, with the understanding that no single way is correct. These neurological differences are not defects, but normal variations of the brain with their own advantages and challenges. Some of these challenges stem largely from how some individuals process and interact with the world in ways that vary more widely and may be less compatible with what is considered the norm. “Neurodivergent” is an umbrella term used to describe individuals whose brains work differently from what society deems typical and is associated with diagnoses such as ADHD, autism, dyslexia, Tourette’s, and others. This term contrasts with “neurotypical”, a term used for neurocognitive functioning that more closely aligns with societal ideas of “normal”. (Rosqvist and Jackson-Perry, 2024)

A note about terminology: The researchers use the term “neurodivergent students,” which is called identity-first language instead of using person-first language (person who is neurodivergent) because it is typically more acceptable to use for neurodivergent conditions, and many of the students they interviewed said being neurodivergent is central to who they are in many ways. They acknowledge the diversity within the neurodivergent space, including differences in preferred terminology.

Following an initial literature review of over 2000 studies, only 23 met the inclusion criteria in their screening protocol, and only four focused on collaborative learning with neurodivergent students in higher education. Recognizing this significant gap in the literature, the research team designed a qualitative study using semi-structured interviews with students who self-identified as neurodivergent. They conducted over 50 interviews with undergraduate and graduate students who identified as neurodivergent across four higher education institutions in the United States and Australia. Each interview typically lasted 30 to 90 minutes and focused on neurodivergent identity, collaborative learning experiences (both specific experiences and broader ideas in general), and recommendations for improving collaborative learning. The data were qualitatively analyzed using both inductive analysis and themes found in the literature.

The presentation centered neurodivergent students’ voices, challenging the tendency to frame neurodivergent learners as the ones who must adapt to neurotypical expectations in group settings, rather than questioning whether those expectations are inclusive in the first place. Excerpts from student interviews helped illustrate the researchers’ findings, and several are included below.

“I have been conditioned my whole life to bend around other people’s needs. I’m always having to make sure that I’m saying this the right way or that I’m not doing something weird, or there are a lot of small adjustments that I’m having to make, and they add up, and it makes me more tired from doing them.”

When analyzing the data, the research team found that almost all interviewees had accommodations, but none applied to collaborative work. As a result, many students reported that they often had to adjust their own behaviors or approaches to be successful in a group context, which puts an unfair burden on them. In addition, some students said that when they asked for an accommodation for group work, faculty reacted with suspicion, assuming they were looking for an “easy way out” of doing the work. Another important finding was that some said they were never explicitly taught the skills necessary for collaborative work; they were expected to figure it out. Students also reported that group formation itself was a stressor. Opinions were mixed about the best way to form groups. Some students prefer to be assigned to a group, while others prefer to choose who they want to work with.

“It’s really disheartening when you try to tell faculty or administration, ‘hey, this method of learning doesn’t work for me, and I am […] willing to do a different thing.’ And they don’t listen or believe you because they think you’re just trying to get off on an easier assignment. That […] damages […] the trust between students and the institution and the faculty. You’re regarding me with pointless suspicion when I’m here because I do want to learn.”

Based on recommendations from the study participants, the research team developed a checklist of guiding questions to support the design of affirming and engaging collaborative learning for neurodivergent students. Because these students often already navigate an educational system built around neurotypical expectations, thoughtfully designed collaboration can reduce barriers rather than create additional ones. There is no one-size-fits-all approach, and the most effective design depends on the students, the activity, and the context, but this checklist provides a good starting point. Ultimately, these practices benefit all students and create more opportunities for everyone to participate and learn effectively.

“I think the main takeaway is– and I think this is useful for everyone– knowing why we’re doing this and how we’re going to do this…Because the worst thing ever is to do something that you don’t see any reason to do it.”

“I feel like we spent a lot of time trying to figure out what actually does the professor want. So I think that if that was clearer, we wouldn’t have had as many moments where I felt like we weren’t being productive… We would have had more to go off of. I feel like that kind of… created an environment where there [were] a lot of question marks.”

“I feel like it’s one of those things they don’t really teach you how to work with other people. They kind of just expect you to know what to do from a younger age. I don’t think in a class I’ve ever been told how to do a project. I don’t think I’ve been told how to work with people.”

“I don’t feel like I’m engaging with all aspects of the project. I didn’t spend any time researching techniques or thinking about what techniques I would use, because my other two group members had already volunteered to take that section. It does come at the cost of me actually feeling like I learned something more from that project. I feel like what I brought to it was everything I already knew.”

Barkley, E. F., Cross, K. P., & Major, C. H. (2014). Collaborative learning techniques: a handbook for college faculty (2nd ed.). Wiley Rosqvist, H. B., & Jackson-Perry, D. (Eds.). (2024). T he Palgrave handbook of research methods and ethics in neurodiversity studies . Palgrave Macmillan.

Источник: Teaching + Learning Lab